Dean Park Estates in North Saanich (generally in the grey area) has a private covenant in place on properties, which prohibits certain uses, such as secondary suites. (Google Maps)

North Saanich’s suite plan at odds with community association

Distirct wants rules to apply to everyone; private restrictions in Dean Park beg to differ

A proposed change to regulations governing secondary suites in North Saanich could leave a local residents’ association on its own to fight new ones in court.

The District of North Saanich is considering making its secondary suites bylaw cover the entire municipality, allowing homeowners to apply to the District to build one as they would anywhere else, and eliminate small pockets of the community where secondary suites are not allowed.

On Monday, council voted to put the idea to the public at a hearing.

Currently, the District has a few exclusion areas — meaning the District will not consider allowing secondary suites in those residential areas, and responds to complaints about them. The most notable exclusion area is the Dean Park Estates subdivision, representing 782 properties. That ‘Secondary Suite Exclusion Area’ was put into place in 2016, after years of going back and forth on the issue.

Now, District council has voted to consider removing that exclusion area following a request this past summer from another neighbourhood, asking for the same thing. A request by residents of the Sandover subdivision made to council June 26 was denied and council asked District staff to report on implications of existing exclusion areas on municipal staff and resources. In a report to council on Oct. 23, staff stated that since 2015, North Saanich has received nine complaints about secondary suites in Dean Park out of a total of 14 complaints on the same topic throughout the District as a whole.

“Overall the Dean Park Exclusion Area has resulted in an increase in bylaw enforcement efforts and an additional demand on the District’s building department for inspections,” stated the report.

Complicating the matter has been the existence of a covenant on those properties within Dean Park Estates. That covenant restricts what people can do on their properties — including not allowing secondary suites — and is overseen by the Dean Park Estates Community Association (DPECA). According to North Saanich’s Chief Administrative Officer Rob Buchan, the covenant is private — between landowners and DPECA — and is not registered with the District. That means any dispute over property use is a matter North Saanich as a municipality would not get involved in.

Over the years, however, the District has gotten involved, specifically with its exclusion area bylaw, and contributed to confusion over who has jurisdiction. Buchan said should council vote to drop the exclusion area at Dean Park Estates, “there’d be nothing (for the District) to enforce) other than its own bylaws, which apply across the municipality.

He said such covenants potentially override local government bylaws, adding that would leave any disputes between homeowners in that subdivision and DPECA a matter for civil courts.

Mayor Alice Finall said the issue has gone back and forth over the years, adding she supported putting the exclusion area in place at Dean Park Estates “for a number of reasons.” Now, she said she’s supporting council’s review of the policy and a public hearing on the matter.

“There are other covenanted areas and one recently asked the District to be excluded (from secondary suites) as well,” Finall said, adding one of the District councillors raised the issue recently, and suggested North Saanich lift the Dean Park Estates exclusion area.

Part of the argument, too, is about North Saanich’s strategic plan which, in part, calls for more variety in housing options.

“Secondary suites already do exist there,” continued the mayor., “The number is as low as 40, but it’s still a noticeable number. And if they do exist, there should be health and safety considerations when they are built.”

Existing bylaws within the District already regulate secondary suites and ensure they’re built to code. A concern among staff and council is suites could pop up in exclusion areas and not be reported and their condition unknown.

Both Buchan and Finall noted a legal opinion for the District on the Dean Park Estates covenant stated restrictions on secondary suites under the DPECA covenant (called statutory building schemes) “not definitive.”

Earlier this year, DPECA and the statutory building schemes was challenged by a resident in civil court. That matter was about an outbuilding, but the homeowner won the case, with the court noting generally that some aspects of the covenant were difficult to enforce.

The News Review has emailed DPECA for comment. In a letter emailed to homeowners in Dean Park Estates on Oct. 30, DPECA stated it favours North Saanich keeping the exclusion area in place “thereby preventing confusion and possible legal actions amongst existing and future property owners…”

Buchan said the idea behind council’s debate on the matter is to reduce confusion. Should the exclusion area be removed, he explained, any dispute over land use would between two parties, not three.

In their letter to residents, DPECA said the loss of the exclusion area would lead to more suites, more cars parked in the streets, more people impacting District services, loss of ability to complain to the District’s bylaw enforcement services and even a decrease in property values. They are encouraging concerned residents to let North Saanich council know their feelings.

No date has been set for the public hearing.

Just Posted

Launch party for Vancouver Island’s new soccer team a success

Over 3,000 seats will be added to Westhills Stadium in the next 6 months

View Royal Park sign taken down after glitch redirects to pornographic website

Resident looking to learn more about workout equipment discovered the problem code

Saanich pedestrian incidents reflect recent trends

76% of crashes involving pedestrians happen at intersections

Two people rescued after falling from lifeboat at Ogden Point

Crew members of the Explorer of the Seas cruise ship fell into the water Thursday night

Online blasting video helps ease Sooke residents concerns

Complaints of dust ongoing since 2017

BC Games’ Athletes Corner: What’s your favourite pump up song?

Check out what’s playing in the earbuds of BC Summer Games athletes before they compete

Big-time racing on tap in Langford this month

Western Speedway the place to be for a roaring good time in summer

BC Wildfire update on Okanagan blazes

Watch the media briefing on the current fire situation in the Okanagan.

Zone 6: Rugby star Maggie Banks carries family legacy to BC Games

Shawnigan Lake student and Coquitlam native following her parents to the national program

RCMP help to save goats from wildfire

The fast-approaching wildfire, sparked Thursday, forced the evacuation of five homes

VIDEO: Near drowning captured on popular B.C. river

Search and Rescue manager says the popular pastime of floating in the summer is inherently dangerous

Crosswalk vandalism leaves black mark for Cowichan as B.C. Games begin

Rainbow crosswalk defaced just days after being painted

Photo gallery: BC Games Day 1

A brief look at action from the 2018 BC Summer Games in the Cowichan Valley

UPDATED: Anti-pipeline campers digging in as eviction deadline expires

The City of Burnaby had ordered the Kinder Morgan pipeline protesters out for violating bylaws

Most Read