Kyoto withdrawal makes sense

Re: Canada must set an example for the world, Guest Comment, Jan. 27, 2012.

Re: Canada must set an example for the world, Guest Comment, Jan. 27, 2012.

Elizabeth May knows full well that although China and India may have signed on to the Kyoto Protocol, as “developing countries,” they were given a “pass” on establishing emission targets until after 2012.

I therefore stand by my comment that some 85 per cent of current world emissions are not covered by Kyoto targets.

To suggest that China, by way of example, has “done far more than Canada” in reducing emissions is unadulterated rubbish.

China is now the largest emitter of emissions in the world, surpassing the U.S. far sooner than expected. In addition, the carbon dragon’s surge in coal use is now the biggest source of emissions in the world.

One can just imagine the targets they will have to achieve after 2012, if in fact targets for such countries are ever established. And under these circumstances, China had the audacity, supported by May, to criticize Canada for its plan to exit this failed protocol.

One can understand, given the circumstances, why Russia and Japan are also withdrawing from Kyoto. No doubt there will be more to follow.

And for May to suggest that there are no penalties associated with failing to meet emission targets in the first commitment leads one to wonder if in fact we are reading the same Kyoto-related documents.

Although there are no direct financial penalties, the protocol specifically states that failure to achieve targets in the first commitment would result in second commitments where countries must make up the difference between increased emissions and targets in the first commitment, plus an additional 30 per cent penalty.

As well, a country’s ability to sell carbon credits would be suspended.

It was in this context that Environment Minister Peter Kent made the $14 billion estimate, an estimate that, in the opinion of many, is far too optimistic.

Canada was absolutely correct in withdrawing from this flawed protocol and other countries, without doubt, will follow the lead of Canada, Russia and Japan in avoiding heavy non-compliance penalties.

Be proud of the fact that Canada is leading the charge to develop emissions targets which will apply to all countries.

Harry Rice

Saanich

 

 

Just Posted

Saanich crash victim leaves behind pregnant wife and young son

The death of a Saanich man has left behind a grieving widow,… Continue reading

Material spill slows traffic on Highway 1 near Victoria

You may experience heavier traffic than normal if you’re headed from Victoria… Continue reading

PACE concert raises $6,500 for Langford family

Cathy Shotton recently donated her kidney to her daughter, Nicki

Cigarette butts the main culprit in lagoon beach cleaup

Thousands of butts were picked up by the Greater Victoria Green team recently

VicPD officers hurt in separate weekend incidents

Both altercations involved aggressive individuals encountered by police

Flu could see greater transmission in 2017

Health asking the public to get their flu vaccinations leading into a flu season that could start early and affect many in 2017.

B.C. NDP convention set for Victoria

Premier, federal leader Jagmeet Singh to add energy

Silver Creek farm search expands north

RCMP were seen collecting evidence three kilometres north of the farm where human remains were found

Flu could see greater transmission in 2017

Health asking the public to get their flu vaccinations leading into a flu season that could start early and affect many in 2017.

Nanaimo man assaulted, tied up and robbed at his home

Incident occurred about 7 a.m. Monday, Oct. 23 at a home on Beverly Drive

B.C. school trustee calls LGBTQ school program ‘weapon of propaganda’

Chilliwack’s Barry Neufeld published the comments on his Facebook page

B.C. casino accused of illegal activity follows rules: operator

B.C. had launched review after concerns about money laundering at River Rock casino in Richmond

Opponents of LGBTQ program to file human rights complaint against Surrey School District

District denied Parents United Canada right to rent Bell Performing Arts Centre for rally next month

Red hot Vikes women to host playoff opener

UVic Vikes This Week: basketball season kicks off at home

Most Read