SEWAGE IN THE CRD Letters: Halifax plant’s failure key part of sewage story

Design mistakes can be catastrophic, former wastewater plant operator says

The Halifax story was interesting, but I was surprised the most important part of their sewage story was missing. After less than one year of operation, the $54-million Halifax Wastewater Treatment Plant had a catastrophic failure in January 2009 and was out of commission until spring of 2010. Repair costs were about $11 million.

During an electrical power outage the back-up generators failed. As a result, a chain of events started from which the plant could not recover because of the way it had been designed, and for its lack of “fail-safe” systems. In just over 20 minutes it was flooded to a depth more than 26 feet.

It was a textbook example of what can go wrong, will go wrong. If a proper risk assessment had been conducted during the design phase, the disaster could have been easily avoided.

The new Halifax Wastewater Treatment Plant was initially a design-build-operate (P3) project with a foreign multinational leading the consortium through one of its subsidiaries. After they tried to change the terms of the operating contract, the city took back the operational component but retained the same consortium to design and build the project.

Surprisingly, Seaterra had selected (for the cancelled McLoughlin Point plant) a consortium that had as a key partner the same multinational responsible for the Halifax plant that failed.

Over the years I have operated many wastewater treatment plants in Ontario and B.C. and there are well-designed plants out there. But there are also, from an operational and ownership perspective, many poorly designed plants based from what I have seen.

Even one small design mistake can turn out to be very costly, as Halifax found out. Hopefully we can learn from the Halifax example.

You can Google “How the sewage plant broke” to read an excellent article on what went wrong and why.

James Lloyd

Colwood

Just Posted

Free firework safety courses coming to the West Shore right before Halloween

No permit? You could be fined anywhere between $100 and $10,000

Fairfield-Gonzales residents aim to establish senior care phone line

The Fairfield-Gonzales Village would allow seniors living alone to have a direct line to resources

Vendors open doors to new futures at Black Press Extreme Education & Career Fair

More tham two dozen employers, educators signed on for Victoria event

Persons Day to be marked with literary readings in Sidney

Peninsula authors to read from their new books relating to women and courageous journeys, Oct. 18

Antimatter 2019: The best in experimental media art comes to Victoria

22nd annual festival of film, performance art and more biggest ever – 120 artists, 30 countries

VIDEO: Greater Victoria, here’s the news you missed this weekend

Dog killed in alleged hit and run, Goodlife Marathon takes over city and more

‘Save the kids!’ Dorian survivor tells the harrowing story of his Canadian wife’s death

Family held a funeral and placed Alishia Liolli’s remains in a niche at a cemetery in Windsor, Ont.

Okanagan woman, 91, votes at advance polls despite broken hip, shoulder and wrist

Angela Maynard has voted in almost every election during her lifetime

Heiltsuk Nation open first Big House in 120 years in northern B.C.

Opening means the community now has an appropriate space for spiritual and ceremonial events

Singh says NDP would form coalition with the Liberals to stop Tories

Singh was in a Liberal-held riding Sunday afternoon in Surrey where he was pressed about his post-election intentions

‘My heart goes out to the mother’: B.C. dad reacts to stabbing death of Ontario boy

Carson Crimeni, who was also 14, was bullied relentlessly, his dad says

The one with the ‘Friends’ photoshoot: Kelowna group recreates TV show intro

A friend’s departure prompted them to create something that really says, “I’ll be there for you”

Canadian Snowbirds plane crashes before air show in Atlanta

Pilot lands safely after ejecting from jet

Share crash data, private insurers tell David Eby, ICBC

B.C. monopoly makes drivers retrieve their own records

Most Read