LETTERS: Climate change and the plea for sanity

Metchosin resident stunned by Tom Fletcher Column

In reading the Dec. 2 column by Tom Fletcher (Inconvenient truths of climate change, B.C. Views), I was stunned by his inaccuracy.

He misused data from a highly contested NASA report, misleading people that climate change is not a significant issue. Then without referencing any source, he wrongly confirmed that Arctic ice is rebounding at an increasing rate. Furthermore, in his pursuit to downplay global warming, he misused data from the International Union of the Conservation of Nature to claim that polar bear populations are not at risk. These claims unjustly persuade people to believe that global warming is either non-existent or trivial.

NASA scientist Jay Zwally, lead author of the recent controversial Antarctic report, stated that “climate warming is taking place in the Antarctic, but to a lesser extent than it is in the Arctic or the rest of the world.” Zwally then said, “I know some of the climate deniers will jump on this report, but it should not take away from the concern about climate warming.”

This leaves anyone who looks into the depth of Fletcher’s claim about NASA’s climate report to see that it is quite misleading. Oddly, the recent NASA report Fletcher cited only uses data up to 2008, and goes against another NASA project known as GRACE, which uses data up to 2014, both measuring changes in Antarctic ice mass. The GRACE reports show that Antarctica is losing over 130 billion tons of ice per year at an increasing rate, while Greenland is losing over 280 billion tons of ice per year.

Therefore, it is untrue for Fletcher to say that NASA, as an organization, confirmed total ice mass in Antarctica is increasing. Debates on Antarctic ice sheets among NASA scientists are highly technical, discussing inaccuracies in satellite laser altimetry, snow science, and measuring gravity anomalies. Their intent was never to fuel the fire for climate change deniers or down-players.

Fletcher claimed that polar bear populations are not at risk, and helped attribute his claim to the International Union for the Conservation of Nature (IUCN). He needs to check his sources better, because the IUCN’s research states that “climate change has a high probability of decreasing the global polar bear population by more than 30 per cent over the next 35 to 40 years.” I will trust that Fletcher is not deliberately lying, but needs to verify his sources before citing important scientific organizations.

To top this all off, Fletcher said he believes climate warming is happening, but that his real problem surrounding climate change is the “misuse of data” and attacks on skeptics. It is clear that Fletcher’s comment on the “misuse of data” is highly hypocritical. He misconstrued the reports of both NASA and the International Union for the Conservation of Nature. This is not meant to be an attack on Fletcher or climate change skeptics, but a plea for them to use reputable peer-reviewed science to form opinions on such a significant issue.

This approach will allow the integrity needed to work together to prevent the potential catastrophes of global warming. We should be thankful that Canada’s new government is committed to uphold objective science, and not disregard it like the Stephen Harper “Fossil Award” days. Now we just have to make sure Justin Trudeau and his cabinet stick to their word.

Dave Cuddy

Metchosin

Just Posted

New roadside testing device can’t identify drug impairment says Vancouver lawyer

Lawyer says similar devices vulnerable to court challenge, testing for drugs different to alcohol

Village Block Party returns to Cook Street

Sunday’s event brings vendors, entertainment and coveted dog race to Victoria’s Cook Street

Thursday sees mix of sun and cloud, high of 22 C

Plus a look ahead at your weekend forecast

Greater Victoria residents among the most credit-worthy Canadians

Yet debt levels continue to rise as Canadians owe $178 for every $100 earned

BC business offers ‘clean start’ for people with employment barriers

CleanStart BC is looks to expand its Victoria staff

Kelowna toddler suffers cracked skull after fall from balcony

Neighbour who found the two-year-old boy said he has a bump the size of a golf ball on his head

Greater Victoria wanted list for the week of May 21

Greater Victoria Crime Stoppers is seeking the public’s help in locating the… Continue reading

POLL: Were you satisfied with the Game of Thrones series finale?

Millions gathered in front of their televisions Sunday night to watch the… Continue reading

RCMP probe if teen was intentionally hit with ski pole by mystery skier on B.C. mountain

The incident happened on March 20 on Grouse Mountain. Police are urging witnesses to come forward

Support growing for orphaned Okanagan child after father dies in highway crash

Family thanks emergency crews for assistance in traumatic incident

Pipeline protester chimes in on Justin Trudeau’s B.C. fundraising speech

The government purchased the Trans Mountain pipeline and expansion project for $4.5 billion

Baby boom seniors putting pressure on B.C. long-term care: report

B.C. leads Canada in growth of dementia, dependence on care

UPDATED: B.C. man says he’ll take People’s Party lawsuit as far as he can

Federal judge shut down Satinder Dhillon’s ‘nonsensical’ motion to bar use of PPC name in byelection

Canada stripping citizenship from Chinese man over alleged marriage fraud

The move comes amid severely strained relations between Ottawa and Beijing

Most Read