Unlike CSI, no slam-dunks in police forensics

Sgt. Nav Hothi

Island District RCMP Sgt. Nav Hothi has the tough job of locating and collecting physical evidence at crime scenes.

Sgt. Nav Hothi

Born: Dartford, England

Years of service: 14,

10 with RCMP foren-

sic identification

One of the challenges facing RCMP forensic identification supervisor Sgt. Nav Hothi is how popular television shows shape the public’s perception of work the unit does.

“One of the effects of TV is what victims of crime expect from watching these shows,” Hothi said. “You feel disheartened because they feel like I’m letting them down based on unrealistic expectations from TV. It’s definitely affected our job.

“When we get to court, for example, juries are under the impression that all of the evidence presented is just like they watched the night before on CSI. They think it’s going to be conclusive, and the case will be a slam dunk.”

Although that does happen occasionally, that’s the exception, not the rule, Hothi said, pointing out that the Robert Pickton murder trial is probably the best-known example of a case solved significantly by science.

“Most cases are solved through good old-fashioned police work, not science,” she said. “We’re only one facet.”

The RCMP forensic identification unit’s work primarily involves working at crime scenes to search for and recover physical evidence.

“In most cases, the officer at the scene decides whether we’re called in, based on training they receive at Depot, and training they’ve received from us,” Hothi explained.

Because it’s so easy to unintentionally remove, obliterate or contaminate evidence, Hothi has a few pointers to pass along.

“If your vehicle has been broken into, try not to drive it or search through it,” she said. “Rain and environmental conditions can come into play. How new is the vehicle how clean is it? ”

If your home has been broken into, Hothi’s best advice is don’t enter.

“That’s as much for safety as preserving evidence,” Hothi noted. “It’s a challenge because your initial response is to make sure everything is okay. Are my kids home, is my pet safe, is my passport still there?

“Not going where the intruder has been until the police arrive makes our job much easier, and greatly increases your chance of recovery. Once someone sits in a chair, they leave evidence and DNA behind. Once someone else sits in that chair, it makes it much harder to find that evidence.”

Unlike the U.S., where there are more civilians than police working in forensics, in Canada there are very few civilians involved in this type of work.

The RCMP typically looks for interested members with a minimum of 3.5 years service. Following an exam, they are invited to do a three-week assessment, based on their score.

“It gives us a chance to see what they can do, and gives them an opportunity to see what the work is like,” Hothi explained. “The three-year apprenticeship is tough, with lots of courses and exams. When you work that hard for it, generally you stay with it for the duration of your career.

“The tough part is that we don’t have the positive interaction with people that is part of a lot of other police work. We only come into people’s lives when something bad has happened.”

For Hothi, however, the rewards far outweigh the challenges.

“We get our job satisfaction from assisting investigators in moving investigations forward. When we hear that a crime has been solved and a culprit has been charged, we’re just as pleased as the victims are. I’m proud to supervise this dedicated, hardworking group of specialists”


—Rick Stiebel is the Langford-RCMP community liaison.

Just Posted

One year later, life is much different in Saanich for the Bui family

‘We still hear cars screeching at the intersection,’ says mom of Leila Bui

Man rescued from sinking boat off the coast of Sidney

Mayday call came into Coast Guard saying vessel had taken on water, BC Ferries dispatched to scene

Fairfield computer store faces $20,000 loss to burglary

Thieves broke into EB Computers on Sunday morning

Save-On-Foods fills up the pantry of Jeneece Place

Retailer stocks up kitchen of local facility for the fourth straight year

Four per cent of Canadian women report being sexually harassed in the workplace

One per cent of men report being sexually harassed in the workplace

Victoria Canadian Tire replaces toys stolen from Salvation Army

Children won’t have to go without toys this Christmas

READER POLL: Do you have turkey or ham for Christmas dinner?

What are you having for Christmas dinner? Canadians gobbled up 3.3 million… Continue reading

Greater Victoria Crime Stoppers wanted list for the week of Dec. 18, 2018

Greater Victoria Crime Stoppers is seeking the public’s help in locating the… Continue reading

‘A stronger Alberta:’ Ottawa announces $1.6B for Canada’s oil and gas sector

Price of Alberta oil plummeted so low that Alberta’s Premier said Canada was practically giving it away

Wicked weather, including heavy snow, rainfall, hammers southern B.C.

Environment Canada has posted winter storm warnings for the Coquihalla Highway, Highway 3

VIDEO: Newcomers join favourites in rounding out Sunfest’s amazing lineup for 2019

The Washboard Union, Cody Johnson, Mitchell Tenpenny, Aaron Goodvin: it just gets better and better

Caretaker jailed, must pay back money after stealing $260K from elderly B.C. couple

Antonette Dizon, now 50, had been hired to provide extra care for Henry and Helen Abfalter

Sea Kings’ final flight holds special meaning for Vancouver Island family

Dozens of people turn out with family of pilot to wave farewell to Sea King helicopters

Retailers feel the squeeze of their generous return policies

Technology data tracking can clamp down on fraudulent abuse

Most Read